Payments Contact us or your insurance carrier directly for assistance. Auto-Owners Insurance 888-252-4626 (After Hours) 517-323-1200 (Regular Hours) Cincinnati Insurance 877-242-2544 (24 Hours) Foremost Insurance 800-527-3907 (24 Hours) State Auto 800-766-1853 (24 Hours) Travelers Travelers 800-842-5075 Bristol West 800-274-7865 (24 Hours) American Modern 800-543-2644 Progressive Insurance 855-347-3939 Liberty Mutual Insurance 1-866-290-2920